- 12 Jul 2016
- [International Secretariat]
- Region: REPUBLIC OF BELARUS
Belarus authorities are using phone networks run by some of the world’s biggest telecoms companies to stifle free speech and dissent, said Amnesty International in a report published today.
The report, It’s enough for people to feel it exists: Civil society, secrecy and surveillance in Belarus, documents how potentially limitless, round-the-clock, unchecked surveillance has a debilitating effect on NGO activists, making basic work, like arranging a meeting over the phone, a risk.
“In a country where holding a protest or criticizing the president can get you arrested, even the threat that the authorities are spying on you can make the work of activists next to impossible,” said Joshua Franco, Technology and Human Rights Researcher at Amnesty International.
“Companies that operate in Belarus have to let authorities have the data they want, when they want it. So if the KGB, for example, wants to spy on them, they don’t need to show a warrant, they don’t need to ask the company to give them access,” said Joshua Franco.
“Telecoms companies have great responsibility. Technology usually empowers free speech, but the spread of communications technology in Belarus has increased the risk of repression. It is vital that telecoms companies resist the abuse of communications technology for outrageously intrusive violations of privacy and free expression.
“The future of online freedom depends on whether telecoms companies challenge governments who overstep the bounds of privacy and free speech, or meekly comply with them to protect their profit margins.”
Stringent state surveillance has a chilling effect on activism
In Belarus, the KGB and other security services have free, non-stop, remote access to both real-time communication and stored data in phone and internet networks.
The report is based on interviews with more than 50 human rights activists, journalists, lawyers, political opposition members, technology experts and others, either in Belarus or in exile, between August 2015 and May 2016. It shows how fear of surveillance impacts privacy, free expression, freedom of peaceful assembly and freedom of association.
Activists told Amnesty International how the total secrecy around surveillance forces them to assume they are subject to surveillance at all times.
Simple tasks such as seeking funding for their organization, making phone calls, or arranging meetings, become fraught with risk, with activists saying they fear their personal or financial information could be used to prosecute, discredit or blackmail them.
“For human rights activists in Belarus, encryption is a last line of defence against a repressive state and its powerful surveillance apparatus. Governments everywhere who want to weaken encryption and empower wider surveillance should beware the potential consequences for human rights,” Joshua Franco.
International telecoms firms implicated
The three largest mobile phone providers in Belarus are partly owned by foreign companies:
- Velcom is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Telekom Austria Group. Telekom Austria told Amnesty International it was obliged to follow Belarusian law. It publishes no information about how access to its Velcom customer data is managed. Telekom Austria is majority ownedby América Móvil. América Móvil did not respond to Amnesty International letters.
- Life:) is 80% owned by the Turkish company Turkcell, which is in turn 38% owned by the Swedish company Teliasonera. Teliasonera told Amnesty International that it has a firm policy opposing direct access to telecoms data, but says it cannot take responsibility for Turkcell’s actions because it is not a majority owner. Turkcell did not respond to Amnesty International letters.
- MTS is jointly owned by the Russian company MTS and Beltelecom, the state-owned Belarusian telecom. MTS (Belarus) did not respond to Amnesty International letters.
Amnesty International believes that the companies are violating well-established standards on business and human rights. Under the UN’s Guiding Principles for Responsible Business, national laws where a company operates cannot be used to justify human rights abuses.
“Intrusive surveillance is not a new phenomenon in Belarus, but what has changed is that technology is taking it to a whole new level. The authorities now have a vast surveillance apparatus at their disposal that allows unrestrained access to private life. The KGB can use phone location records to see where people are and who is with them. People’s mobile phones are now like police officers in their pockets,” said Joshua Franco.
7 July 2016
AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL PRESS RELEASE
- 1 Dec 2021
DETAINED RIGHTS DEFENDER DENIED MEDICAL CARE
- 6 Aug 2021
HUMAN RIGHTS DEFENDERS REMAIN IN DETENTION
- 1 Jun 2021
JOURNALIST FACING TORTURE AFTER ABDUCTION
- 23 Dec 2020
TORTURED DETAINEE DENIED MEDICAL CARE
- 30 Nov 2020
CHILDREN’S HOSPICE AT RISK, DIRECTOR TARGETED
- 20 Jun 2018 [International Secretariat]
REPUBLIC OF BELARUS: Unprecedented Supreme Court decision to suspend death sentences
- 17 Mar 2017 [International Secretariat]
REPUBLIC OF BELARUS: Biggest crackdown in years as dozens detained at peaceful protests
- 8 Dec 2016 [International Secretariat]
REPUBLIC OF BELARUS: Three executions feared in as many weeks amid ‘sudden and shameful purge’ of death row
- 26 Apr 2012
REPUBLIC OF BELARUS: Belarus urged to free remaining prisoners of conscience after two released
- 6 Dec 2011
REPUBLIC OF BELARUS: Two sentenced to death over Minsk metro bombing